Penstemon haydenii

S. Wats.

Blowout Penstemon

G2Imperiled Found in 2 roadless areas NatureServe Explorer →
G2ImperiledGlobal Rank
HighThreat Impact
Blowout penstemon (Penstemon haydenii). Photo by U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, Public Domain (U.S. Government Work), via ECOS.
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, https://www.usa.gov/government-works
Identity
Unique IDELEMENT_GLOBAL.2.135060
Element CodePDSCR1L300
Record TypeSPECIES
ClassificationSpecies
Classification StatusStandard
Name CategoryVascular Plant
Endemicendemic to a single nation
KingdomPlantae
PhylumAnthophyta
ClassDicotyledoneae
OrderPlantaginales
FamilyPlantaginaceae
GenusPenstemon
Other Common Names
Blowout Beardtongue (EN) blowout beardtongue (EN)
Concept Reference
Kartesz, J.T. 1994. A synonymized checklist of the vascular flora of the United States, Canada, and Greenland. 2nd edition. 2 vols. Timber Press, Portland, OR.
Conservation Status
Rank Method Rank calculation - Biotics v2
Review Date2023-02-01
Change Date2023-02-01
Edition Date2023-01-31
Edition AuthorsOliver, L. (2010), rev. Eberly (2023)
Threat ImpactHigh
Range Extent20,000-200,000 square km (about 8000-80,000 square miles)
Number of Occurrences21 - 80
Rank Reasons
Penstemon haydenii is a perennial herb that occurs in the Nebraska Sandhills and Ferris Dunes of southcentral Wyoming. It is restricted to a unique dynamic habitat of sandhills and dunes where there is active wind erosion that creates depressions called blowouts. This species occurs on early successional, sparsely vegetated, blowouts. Prior to settlement, there were greater amounts of habitat with natural processes in place to fuel the dynamic system, but dune stabilization and land conversion has reduced the amount of available habitat. As a result, existing blowouts are isolated, creating barriers to seed dispersal and pollen exchange. While bottlenecks may have occurred, this species, which reproduces vegetatively most frequently, does have some ability to rebound in the face of environmental change as the seed bank harbors genetic potential. Threats to this species largely fall into two categories: lack of disturbance in Nebraska and destabilization of the dune systems in Wyoming. Most populations are small and vulnerable to stochastic events and already exhibiting downward trends. While there are some measures taken to the protect this species, its habitat requires landscape level management efforts coordinated across the private and public sector, which are challenging to initiate and maintain long term.
Range Extent Comments
Penstemon haydenii is a regional endemic of the western United States that occurs in the Nebraska Sand Hills and the Ferris Dunes of southcentral Wyoming in Carbon County (Heidel 2022, USFWS 2022). The Nebraska Sand Hills form the largest sand dune system in North America, covering 5 million ha and intersecting 20 counties (Stokes and Swinehart 1997). By contrast the Ferris Dunes, about 322 km away, covers only around 50000 ha (Heidel 2022).
Occurrences Comments
Each occurrence is comprised of a few to many blowouts. In Wyoming, it is known from three occurrences, with 18 of the 22 occupied dunes comprising the one main occurrence. As of 2023, there are approximately 40 native occurrences seen in the last 20 years and 49 occurrences with introduced plants. The number of biologically distinct populations within the documented occurrences should be examined.
Threat Impact Comments
Threats to this species are complicated and rely on landscape level solutions that involve many partners, public and private. In Nebraska, the predominate threats are around the stabilization (lack of disturbance) of active blowouts and conversely, in Wyoming, the predominate stressors threaten to destabilize these systems. In Nebraska, fire suppression and range management practices to reduce wind erosion and promote grassland for grazing, threaten the active blowout habitat with degradation and loss (Caha et al. 1997, USFWS 2012, 2022). Before settlement, fire by lightning and those set purposefully by Native Americans, burned large areas of the plains that left open and exposed areas. These exposed areas along with grazed areas from bison, along with the strong northwesterly winds created habitats known as blowouts (Caha et al. 1998). Intensive livestock grazing was similarly beneficial (USFWS 2012) but current practices promote healthy grasslands with the use of rotational grazing (G. Steinauer, pers. comm., 2023). Since Penstemon haydenii colonizes windy, sandy barrens and declines when vegetation becomes established (Stubbendieck et al. 1989, Tepedino et al. 2006), the active blowout habitat is essential to its survival.

Habitat loss and eventual fragmentation of sites is concerning as it can limit pollination exchange, leading to inbreeding depression (Caha et al. 1998) and seed dispersal (USFWS 2012). A related compounding issue is the decline of pollinators (USFWS 2012). Herbivory of plants by native ungulates is a threat near the paths at some sites in Wyoming, as it can make plant vulnerable to burial (USFWS 2012). The predation of seeds and seedlings by rodents reduces successful regeneration and the effectiveness of planted materials (USFWS 2012).

In Wyoming, the predominate threats are energy development, oil and gas exploration and development, quarrying (sand), and recreational use of ORVs (USFWS 2012). A potential threat is collection for horticultural purposes or by passersby, as this species is quite attractive (USFWS 2012). Climate change, prolonged drought, and decreasing precipitation, could impact the species at various points in its life cycle but also destabilize the dune systems (Tilini et al. 2016, Heidel 2022, USFWS 2022).

Additional rangewide threats include invasive plant species and pests and pathogens (USFWS 2012, Heidel 2022).

Around 60% of the known occurrences are on private land, leaving them vulnerable to many potential stressors (USFWS 2022). Appropriate management of the dune systems requires coordinated approaches across public land managers and private land owners, which is challenging and sensitive to changes in individual desires.
Ecology & Habitat

Diagnostic Characteristics

Adapted from Freeman (1981), Weedon et al. (1982a) Stubbendieck et al. (1982), and Lichvar (1982): Distinguished from P. grandiflorus by blue corolla rather than pinkish, and long, narrow leaves rather than roundish. Distinguished from P. angustifolius by its larger, lighter blue flowers rather than the smaller, darker blue flowers of P. angustifolius. Penstemon haydenii is noted by strong, fragrant odor (Weedon et al., 1982). Also, P. grandiflorus has never been observed in or on the rims of blowouts (Stubbendieck et al., 1982).

Habitat

Penstemon haydenii inhabits early successional, sparsely vegetated, sand dunes with depressions created by wind erosion referred to as blowouts (Heidel 2022). In Nebraska, these are found in sandhills prairie (Stubbendieck et al. 1989, Kuchler 1964, Pool 1914). The term 'blowout' refers to a naturally occurring depression in the Nebraska Sandhills. These depressions are caused when vegetation at the upper slope of a hill is disturbed, typically by fire or grazing animals. The 'blowout' may take as many as ten years to become a full scale and active blow out. The process is started when sand is deposited from the windward side of the slope to the leeward side, and this process continues until eventually the roots of the surrounding vegetation are exposed and finally ripped up by the force of the wind. Eventually, a crater is created where there is constant wind action, so succession is continually taking place (Stubbendieck et al. 1989). As a pioneer species, it establishes within the blowout, usually near the leeward side only, after the sand has stabilized, but it declines once vegetation (prairie grasses and forbs) establish and the blowout begins to "heal" (USFWS 2022).

All sites have less than 10% basal ground cover (Heidel 1981). Initial colonization of dunes is by Redfieldia flexuosa. Psoralea lanceolata, Redfieldia flexuosa, and Calamovilfa longifolia are common associates in Nebraska and Wyoming (Heidel 1981, 2022). Other associated plants include Andropogon hallii (NE only), Artemisia campestris, Asclepias arenaria, Astragalus longifolia, Calomovilfa longifolia, Cirsium plattensis, Helianthus spp., Hymenopappus corymbosus, Lathyrus polymorphus, Linum sulcatum, Lithospermum incisum, Lygodesmia rostrata, Muhlenbergia pungens (NE only), Oenothera serrulata, Oryzopsis hymenoides, Petalostemum villosum, Rumex venosus, Tradescantia occidentalis, and Yucca glauca (Heidel 1981, 2022, Lichvar 1982).

Ecology

Penstemon haydenii is well adapted to survival in blowout dunes habitat. It can recover from sand burial (Barr 1944) and develop adventitious roots from buried stem and leaf nodes (Barr 1951). Habitat erosion and shifting sand can expose the seed bank, prompting seed germination (Heidel 2022). The nearly horizontal rootstocks produce numerous fibrous roots, providing strong anchorage in the sands (Weedon et al. 1982). Colonization is primarily by seedlings, which take 3 or more years to establish. Barr (1951) noted that a seedling 4-5" tall often has roots over 1' long. Established plants, and even seedlings to some degree, can tolerate burial by sands, sending up new shoots from the crown; this suggests this species may be long-lived (Heidel 2022). Bees are the primary pollinators (Weedon et al. 1982, Tepedino et al. 2006, 2007). Penstemon haydenii appears to bloom in alternate years, and this may be tied to moisture cycles (Stubbendieck, pers. comm.). While in bloom, P. haydenii produces large quantities of seed. Seed weight is 125,000 per pound (Stubbendick et al., 1982). Barr (1946) believed that the tendency to bloom profusely in certain years makes the plant vulnerable to weather conditions and local extinctions. Its life history appears tuned to recurrently invading newly formed blowouts (Weedon et al., 1982), and it declines under competition from other colonizing species (Weedon et al., 1982; Lichvar, per. comm.), particularly Andropogon hallii (Stubbendieck, pers. comm.). Freedom from moisture competition may be significant (Barr 1951).

Artificial propagation studies are underway. The following results are from Stubbendieck et al. (1982, 1983). Seeds were collected in August 1981 in Garden County, Nebraska from the largest known population. Stubbendieck et al. (1982) found that scarification (especially removal of the radicle end of the seed) increased germination success from the normal 10% to 60%. Allowing seeds to inbibe water 12 to 24 hours prior to scarification improved germination success to 90-95% and may indicate the presence of a water-soluble inhibitor (Stubbendieck et al., 1982). Seedlings were grown in tubes in the greenhouse for approximately 90 days. In May 1982, 297 transplants were placed into blowouts in Cherry, Thomas and Grant counties. At each blowout site, 33 plants were placed at each of 3 locations: in the depression or area of sand removal; on the leeward side of the rim; and on the windward or sand deposit side of the rim. A fourth location was on disturbed, bare sand near the Platte River in Phelps County, Nebraska (Stubbendieck et al., 1982). There was a 90% survival rate 3 weeks after transplant (Stubbendieck et al, 1982). Cattle trampling appears to have destroyed most of the seedlings in the blowout depressions at two locations. The survival rate at the end of the first growing season for remaining transplants was 83% (Stubbendieck et al., 1983).

This species is mycorrhizal with an AM fungus in the fine endophyte group, Glomus tenue, identified on fine roots of a juvenile plant (Heidel 2022).

Reproduction

The Blowout Penstemon reproduces most frequently by vegetative propagation (Caha et al. 1998). It is believed to be self-incompatible, and requires pollinators for pollination to take place and to produce seed (Tepedino et al. 2007). Rodents may be one method of seed dispersal (USFWS 2012), but the seeds have appendages that would aid in wind dispersal of what is a relatively large and heavy seed amongst the dune species (Heidel 2022).. Seeds under deep substrate, in the seedbank, do not germinate until habitat erosion exposes them (Tilini et al. 2017, Heidel 2022). Seedlings take three or more years to become established plants (Heidel 2022).
Terrestrial Habitats
Sand/dune
Other Nations (1)
United StatesN2
ProvinceRankNative
NebraskaS1Yes
WyomingS2Yes
Threat Assessments
ThreatScopeSeverityTiming
2 - Agriculture & aquacultureRestricted (11-30%)Serious - moderateHigh (continuing)
2.3 - Livestock farming & ranchingRestricted (11-30%)Serious - moderateHigh (continuing)
2.3.4 - Scale unknown/unrecordedRestricted (11-30%)Serious - moderateHigh (continuing)
3 - Energy production & miningSmall (1-10%)Serious - moderateHigh (continuing)
3.2 - Mining & quarryingSmall (1-10%)UnknownHigh (continuing)
3.3 - Renewable energySmall (1-10%)Serious - moderateHigh (continuing)
4 - Transportation & service corridorsSmall (1-10%)Serious - slightHigh (continuing)
4.1 - Roads & railroadsSmall (1-10%)Serious - slightHigh (continuing)
5 - Biological resource useSmall (1-10%)UnknownLow (long-term)
5.2 - Gathering terrestrial plantsSmall (1-10%)UnknownLow (long-term)
5.2.1 - Intentional use (species being assessed is the target)Small (1-10%)UnknownLow (long-term)
6 - Human intrusions & disturbanceRestricted - smallModerate - slightHigh (continuing)
6.1 - Recreational activitiesRestricted - smallModerate - slightHigh (continuing)
7 - Natural system modificationsPervasive (71-100%)Serious or 31-70% pop. declineHigh (continuing)
7.1 - Fire & fire suppressionPervasive (71-100%)Serious or 31-70% pop. declineHigh (continuing)
8 - Invasive & other problematic species, genes & diseasesUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
8.1 - Invasive non-native/alien species/diseasesUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
8.1.1 - Unspecified speciesUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
8.2 - Problematic native species/diseasesUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
8.2.1 - Unspecified speciesUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
11 - Climate change & severe weatherUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)
11.2 - DroughtsUnknownUnknownHigh (continuing)

Plant Characteristics
DurationPERENNIAL, Short-lived
Economic Value (Genus)No
Roadless Areas (2)
Idaho (1)
AreaForestAcres
Bear CreekCaribou-Targhee National Forest118,582
South Dakota (1)
AreaForestAcres
Indian CreekBuffalo Gap National Grassland24,666
References (48)
  1. Barr, C. 1944. Through the Nebraska Sandhills. Bulletin of the American Rock Garden Society, 2(6):105-108.
  2. Barr, C. 1946. The life span of penstemons. Bulletin of the American Rock Garden Society, 4(4):59-61.
  3. Barr, C. 1951. An open heart for penstemons. Nat. Horticultural Mag. 30(1): 29-31.
  4. Blomquist, F. and B. Heidel. 2002. 2002 Census of Blowout penstemon (Penstemon haydenii) at Bear Mountain - Junk Hill population (EO#002). 25 and 27 June.
  5. Bragg, T. B. 1978. Effects of burning, cattle grazing, and topography on vegetation of the choppy sands range site in the Nebraska Sandhill Prairie. Proc. First Int'l rangelands Cong. pp. 248-253.
  6. Brinegar, T.E. and Keim, F.D. (1942). The relations of vegetative composition and cattle grazing on Nebraska rangeland. Nebraska Agr. Exp. Stat. Res. Bull. 123, 39 pp.
  7. Britton, N. L. and A. Brown. 1913. An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States and Canada. 3 vol. Dover Publications, Inc., N. Y. 2052 pp.
  8. Caha, C. A., D. J. Lee, J. Stubbendieck. 1997. Organellar genetic diversity in <i>Penstemon haydenii</i> (Scrophulariaceae): an endangered plant species. American Journal of Botany 85(12): 1704-1709.
  9. Ferris, J.F. and Hulbert, L.C. 1980. Effect of fire and soil on composition of bluestem prairie in Kansas. Unpubl. manuscript, 15 pp.
  10. Fertig, W. 2001. 2000 survey for Blowout penstemon (Penstemon haydenii) in Wyoming. Prepared for the Bureau of Land Management Wyoming State Office by the Wyoming Natural Diversity Database, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY.
  11. Flicker, J. 1982. Memorandum to John Humke, The Nature Conservancy, June 17, 1982, 3 pp.
  12. Flora of North America Editorial Committee (FNA). 2019. Flora of North America north of Mexico. Vol. 17: Magnoliophyta: Tetrachondraceae to Orobanchaceae. Oxford Univ. Press, New York. xxiv + 737 pp.
  13. Freeman, G.C. 1981. A biosystematic study of the genus Penstemon (Scrophulariaceae) in the Great Plains. M.S. thesis, Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas.
  14. Frolik, A.L. and Shepherd, W.D. 1940. Vegetative composition and grazing capacity of a typical area of Nebraska Sandhills rangeland. Nebraska Agr. Exp. Stat. Res. Bull. 17, 39 pp.
  15. Heidel, B. 1981. Habitat characterization at known Penstemon haydenii occurrences. Unpublished report, The Nature Conservancy, June 20, 1981, 2 pp.
  16. Heidel, B. 2017. Completion of private land surveys for Penstemon haydenii (Blowout penstemon) - 2016, Carbon County, Wyoming. Prepared for the USDI Fish & Wildlife Service – Ecological Services Office by the Wyoming Natural Diversity Database - University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY.
  17. Heidel, B. 2022. <i>Penstemon haydenii </i>(Blowout penstemon, Blowout beardtongue) monitoring synthesis and species status report, Carbon County, Wyoming. Prepared for: Bureau of Land Management State Office and Rawlins Field Office. Wyoming Natural Diversity Database, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY.
  18. Heidel, Bonnie. Personal Communication. Lead Botanist. Wyoming Natural Diversity Database. University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY
  19. Heitlinger, M. (1982). Memorandum to John Flicker, The Nature Conservancy, July 7, 1982, 3 pp.
  20. Kartesz, J.T. 1994. A synonymized checklist of the vascular flora of the United States, Canada, and Greenland. 2nd edition. 2 vols. Timber Press, Portland, OR.
  21. Kuchler, A.W. 1964. Potential natural vegetation of the conterminous United States. Am. Geographic Society, Spec. Publ. no. 36, 116 pp.
  22. Lichvar, R.W. 1982. Status report on Penstemon haydenii S. Watson. Report to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 25 pp.
  23. Nebraska Rare Plants ad hoc committee. 1976. Rare native vascular plants of Nebraska. 32 pp.
  24. Pennell, F.W. 1935. The Scrophulariaceae of eastern temperate North America. Monographs of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 1. 650 pp.
  25. Pool, R.J. 1914. A study of the vegetation of the Sandhills of Nebraska. Minnesota Botanical Studies 3(4): 189.
  26. Rydberg, P.A. 1895. Flora of the Sandhills of Nebraska. Contrib. of the U.S. National Herbarium, 13(3): 172, 199.
  27. Steinauer, Gerry. Personal Communication. Nebraska Natural Heritage Program Botanist. Game and Parks Commission, Lincoln, NE
  28. Stokes, S., and J. B. Swinehart. 1997. Middle- and late-Holocene dune reactivation in the Nebraska Sand Hills, USA. The Holocene 7(3):263-272
  29. Stubbendieck, J. 2001. Unpublished census records of Penstemon haydenii in Nebraska. Distributed at FWS meeting in Grand Island, ND.
  30. Stubbendieck, J., Engel, R., Schact, W., Traeger, J., and Weedon, R. 1982a. Germination characteristics of <i>Penstemon haydenii </i>Wats. Proc. Neb. Acad. Sci. 102-118.
  31. Stubbendieck, J., J. Traeger, and R. Weedon. 1983. Propagation of blowout penstemon (Penstemon haydenii S. Wats.). Abs. presented to Nebraska Academy of Sciences, April, 1983.
  32. Stubbendieck, J., T.R. Flessner and R.R. Weedon. 1989. Blowouts in the Nebraska sandhills: the habitat of Penstemon haydenii. 11th North American Prairie Conference, Proc. pp. 223-225.
  33. Stubbendieck, J., Weedon, R., Traeger, J., and Lindgren, D. 1982b. Blowout penstemon (<i>Penstemon haydenii </i>S. Watson): Description, status, and culture of a rare species. Amer. Penstemon Soc. Bull. 41-1:4-6.
  34. Tepedino, V.J., T.R. Toler, B.A Bradley, J.L. Hawk, and T.L. Griswold. 2007. Pollination biology of a disjunct population of the endangered sandhills endemic <i>Penstemon haydenii </i>S. Wats. (Scrophulariaceae) in Wyoming, USA. Plant Ecology 193:59–69.
  35. Tepedino, V. J., W. R. Bowlin, and T. L. Griswold. 2006. Pollination biology of the endandgered Blowout Penstemon <i>(Penstemon haydenii </i>S. Wats.: Scrophulariaceae) in Nebraska. Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 133(4): 548-559.
  36. Tilini, K.L., S.E. Meyer, and P.S. Allen. 2016. Breaking primary seed dormancy in Gibbens' beardtongue (<i>Penstemon gibbensii</i>) and blowout penstemon (<i>Penstemon haydenii</i>). Native Plants Journal 17(3):256-265.
  37. Tilini K.L., S.E. Meyer, and P.S. Allen. 2017. Seed bank dynamics of blowout penstemon in relation to local patterns of sand movement on the Ferris Dunes, south-central Wyoming. Botany 95: 819–828.
  38. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). 1987. Final rule to determine <i>Penstemon haydenii</i> (blowout Penstemon) to be an endangered species. Fed. Register. 52(169):32926-32929.
  39. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). 1992. Blowout penstemon (<i>Penstemon haydenii</i>) recovery plan. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Denver, Colorado. 42 pp.
  40. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). 2012. Blowout Penstemon (<i>Penstemon haydenii</i>) 5-Year Review: Summary and Evaluation. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Nebraska Ecological Services Field Office, Grand Island, Nebraska.
  41. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). 2022. Blowout penstemon (<i>Penstemon haydenii</i>) 5-year status review. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Grand Island, Nebraska. 7 pp.
  42. Watson, S. 1891. Botanical Gazette 16: 311.
  43. Weedon, R. 1982. Personal communication to John Flicker, in a memorandum to John Humke, The Nature Conservancy, June 17, 1982.
  44. Weedon, R., D.J. Norton, and J. Stubbendieck. 1983. Blowout penstemon: a rare sandhills endemic (Nebraska). Rest. and Mgmt. Notes 1(3):26.
  45. Weedon, R., J. Stubbendieck, and M. Beel. 1982a. Notes on Nebraska flora: blowout penstemon. NEBRASKAland. June 1982: 49-51.
  46. Weedon, R., J. Stubbendieck J., and D. Norton. 1982b. The botanical contributions of Claude A. Barr II. American Penstemon Soc., Bull., 41-1:6-9.
  47. Westover, D.E. 1977. Nebraska wildfires. Dept. Forestry, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Neb. 20 pp.
  48. Wolfe, C.W. 1973. Effects of fire on a sandhills grassland environment. Proc. Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecol. Conf., no. 12: 241-265.