Primula frenchii

(Vasey) A.R. Mast & Reveal

French's Shootingstar

G3Vulnerable (G3?) Found in 2 roadless areas NatureServe Explorer →
G3VulnerableGlobal Rank
High - mediumThreat Impact
Identity
Unique IDELEMENT_GLOBAL.2.160308
Element CodePDPRI03060
Record TypeSPECIES
ClassificationSpecies
Classification StatusStandard
Name CategoryVascular Plant
Endemicendemic to a single nation
KingdomPlantae
PhylumAnthophyta
ClassDicotyledoneae
OrderPrimulales
FamilyPrimulaceae
GenusPrimula
Synonyms
Dodecatheon frenchii(Vasey) Rydb.
Other Common Names
French's shootingstar (EN)
Concept Reference
Kartesz, J.T. 1994. A synonymized checklist of the vascular flora of the United States, Canada, and Greenland. 2nd edition. 2 vols. Timber Press, Portland, OR.
Taxonomic Comments
The taxonomic distinctiveness of Dodecatheon frenchii has been called into question given that only one morphologic character distinguishes it from D. meadii, however D. frenchii is a diploid and D. meadii is a tetraploid. Oberle and Esselman (2011) show that these two species are distinct but local hybridization exists and may have contributed to taxonomic confusion in the past.
Conservation Status
Rank MethodLegacy Rank calculation - Excel v3.1x
Review Date2018-10-10
Change Date2018-10-10
Edition Date2018-10-10
Edition AuthorsOstlie, W. (MRO) (1990), rev. Treher (2018), rev. L. Oliver (2018)
Threat ImpactHigh - medium
Range Extent20,000-2,500,000 square km (about 8000-1,000,000 square miles)
Number of Occurrences81 - 300
Rank Reasons
Dodecatheon frenchii occurs in "rockhouses" on moist sandstone cliffs. The majority of the range is in southern Illinois and adjacent states with sites disjunct in Arkansas, Alabama and Kentucky. There are a number of threats that include development, recreation activities, deer browse and genetic degradation.
Range Extent Comments
Dodecatheon frenchii occurs just south of the glacial boundary primarily in the Shawneetown ridge in southern Illinois and adjacent states, with outlying occurrences in northwestern Arkansas, Alabama, and eastern Kentucky (Oberle and Esselman 2011). The range extent was calculated to be approximately 204,000 sq km using locational data from SEINet (2018), however, a range was selected to account for specimens with no locational data.
Occurrences Comments
There are between 81 and 100 documented occurrences. There is one in Alabama, twenty in Illinois, 33 in Indiana, seven in Missouri, five in Arkansas, and thirty-four in Kentucky.
Threat Impact Comments
Inadequate timber management practices within D. frenchii habitat appear to be the primary threat to the species (Tucker pers. comm.). Desiccation of habitat by loss of shade-producing trees may have a negative effect on populations (Hill 2002). At present, no extant populations are known from areas that have been impacted in any way by timber harvest (Tucker pers. comm.).

Since all known populations of D. frenchii in Kentucky occur in rock shelters, digging of archeological artifacts is a significant threat to the species (Evans pers. comm., Bowles and Kurz 1981). Such activities destroy the substrate upon which it grows.

Large habitat areas are attractive to recreationist using off-road vehicles (Schwegman pers. comm.). Some of the best populations in Illinois have been destroyed by these vehicles (Schwegman pers. comm., Bowles and Kurz 1981). Destruction may occur via physical damage to the plants as well as compaction of soil around the surficial, horizontal plant roots (Bowles and Kurz 1981). Soil compaction may also retard seedling development and survival.

Development is also a threat and causes habitat fragmentation further limiting dispersal (Hill 2002).

Deer trampling has negatively affected some populations in Illinois (Schwegman pers. comm.). Moderate levels of trampling are apparently common-place in French's shooting-star habitat. Occurring at the bases of cliffs and bluffs, plants frequently occur adjacent to foot trails or animal trails (Tucker pers. comm.). Excessive trampling is thought to be detrimental to the species.

Seed dispersal into unoccupied habitat is limited by the scarce availability of rockhouses, and therefore this species may be unable to increase its range quickly (Hill 2002).

Climate change is another likely threat to the species (pers. comm. M. Underwood Briggler).
Ecology & Habitat

Diagnostic Characteristics



In the past, Dodecatheon frenchii was thought to be a variety or ecological morph of Dodecatheon meadii. Detailed scientific work by Voigt and Swayne (1955) and Olah and Defilipps (1968) respectively determined that D. frenchii was a distinct taxon based upon phenotypic and genotypic differences.

Habitat



Dodecatheon frenchii has a small geographic range extending from southern Illinois to eastern Missouri and Arkansas, Indiana and western Kentucky (Hauser et al. 1981). It is found in close association to sandstone ledges, overhangs and bluffs, preferring north and east-facing exposures (Tucker 1982, Mohlenbrock 1978). French's shooting-star grows in habitats which yield little competition from other plant species, often growing alone in bare soil.

In Arkansas, Dodecatheon frenchii is found occasionally in large numbers in areas that have not been impacted by timber management (Tucker pers. comm.). To date, the species is found in only two counties within the state, Newton (numerous occurrences) and Cleburne (one occurrence).

All occurrences of D. frenchii within Kentucky are known from sandstone rock-shelters, ranging in size from very small overhangs to large shelters (Evans pers. comm.). Substrates on which the species occurs are composed typically of sandy soil. Often, the species grows by itself, with no associated plant species.

In Illinois, D. frenchii has been reported within a 10-mile wide belt in the extreme southern portion of the state (Voigt and Swayne 1955). The species has been found under sandstone ledges or "rock houses" (Schwegman pers. comm., Olah and DeFilipps 1969) in canyons of streams that flow predominantly southward (Voigt and Wayne 1955). It is apparently found most frequently under north and east-facing bluffs, growing in areas where light readings are 14-25 percent less than the 5000-6000 foot candles recorded for D. meadii habitat. Soil layers upon which the plants grow are composed primarily of sandy residuum or unweathered loess (Kurz and Bowles 1981). Parietaria pensylvanica is a common associate (Schwegman pers. comm.). Additional associates include Cardamine arenicola, Cardemine pensylvancia and Samolus parviflorus in wet sites, and Chenopodium hybridum in dry sites (Kurz and Bowles 1981).

Extant populations in Indiana are known from Crawford and Perry Counties (Hauser et al. 1981). Within the state, French's shooting-star occupies the sides of steep, moist sandstone cliffs, often under overhangs. Plants occur on all aspects but typically remain shaded due to overhanging sandstone ledges (Homoya pers. comm.). Associates include Lycopodium selago-patens, Hydrangea arborescens, Asplenium pinnatifidum, Sedum ternatum, Polypodium vulgare and Heuchera parviflora (Hauser et al. 1981). Lycopodium selago-patens and Heuchera parviflora appear to be excellent indicators.

In Missouri, D. frenchii is apparently restricted to the lowest sandstone ledges and shelves of north-facing overhangs (Nelson 1979). Such environments are cool, moist, humid and relatively dark. Associates include cinnamon fern (Osmunda cinnamomea), hayscented fern (Dennstaedtia punctiloba) and lady fern (Athyrium filix-femina).

Ecology

French's shooting-star is a diploid (2n = 44) species (Olah and DeFilipps 1968). Since D. meadii is a tetraploid (2n = 88), hybrid sterility is likely as a barrier to interbreeding between the two taxa. High stainability of pollen (indicating fertility) is evident in both species. Both characteristics (different ploidy levels and high pollen fertility levels) lend credence to the specific elevation of both taxa (Olah and DeFillips 1968).

French's shooting-star typically grows as a pioneer species, protected beneath sandstone overhangs. Buffered from outside influences, D. frenchii begins seasonal development early in the spring. According to Biotic Consultants (1976), the average date for the appearance of the first leaf is between the 13th and 28th of February. Individual plants may form as many as 10 basal leaves. Flowering occurs as early as mid-March and can continue until late April. In southern Illinois, flowering occurs between March 14 and April 27 (Mohlenbrock 1978). A given plant can produce as many as 15 flowers, but this is not common. Seed capsules begin to form before the petals have withered away. By the end of May, leaves have begun to turn yellow and fruits are relatively large (up to 6 mm in length). Seeds mature by the end of June and are shed immediately. By early July, most plants have died (Biotic Consultants 1976).

The breeding system of D. frenchii is unknown, but it is assumed to be cross-pollinated by insects, as are most other species of the genus (Tucker 1982). The only insects that have been observed visiting D. frenchii flowers in Arkansas have been very small Dipterans and some small bees (Tucker 1982). According to Tucker (1982), extensive visitation by insects to D. frenchii flowers apparently does not occur. In a study of the pollination ecology of the closely related D. amethystinum, however, small bees and flies were frequently seen visiting the flowers, but none were actually involved with the pollination of the plants (Macior 1970). The only effective pollinators of D. amethystinum were the queens of Bombus affinis, B. griseocollis, B. impatiens, B. vagans and B. nevadensis auricomus, with the exception of B. bimaculatus, where queens and drones were equally effective (Macior 1970). Similar and/or identical species may effectively pollinate D. frenchii flowers as well. For an in-depth description of the foraging and pollination behavior of Bombus bees on D. amethystinum, see Macior (1970).

Seed dispersal occurs as capsules open, releasing the seeds (Tucker 1982). It is thought that seeds accumulate within the soil forming a seed bank within close proximity to the parent plants. Ant-lions and ants have been frequently observed in close proximity to seedlings, but it is not known whether they play a role in seed dispersal (Tucker 1982).
Other Nations (1)
United StatesN3
ProvinceRankNative
IndianaS3Yes
AlabamaS1Yes
MissouriS1Yes
KentuckyS3Yes
ArkansasS2Yes
IllinoisS3Yes
Threat Assessments
ThreatScopeSeverityTiming
1 - Residential & commercial developmentLarge - restrictedUnknownHigh (continuing)
1.3 - Tourism & recreation areasLarge - smallUnknownUnknown
8 - Invasive & other problematic species, genes & diseasesPervasive - largeUnknownHigh (continuing)
11 - Climate change & severe weatherLarge - smallUnknownHigh (continuing)
12 - Other optionsRestricted - smallUnknownHigh (continuing)
12.1 - Other threatRestricted - smallUnknownHigh (continuing)

Plant Characteristics
DurationPERENNIAL
Economic Value (Genus)No
Roadless Areas (2)
Illinois (2)
AreaForestAcres
Bay CreekShawnee National Forest120
Burden FallsShawnee National Forest485
References (21)
  1. Baker, B. and T. Witsell. 2018. Final report on <i>Claytonia arkansana </i>Yatsk. R. Evans &amp; Witsell [Arkansas spring-beauty], <i>Neviusia alabamensis </i> A. Gray [Alabama snow-wreath], <i>Primula frenchii </i>(Vasey) A. R. Mast &amp; Reveal [French's shooting-star], and <i>Silene ovata </i> Pursh [Ovate-leaf catchfly] Survey and Research work in Arkansas 2017. Report prepared and submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Arkansas Natural Heritage Commission.
  2. Biotic Consultants, Inc. 1976. Endangered, threatened and rare plants of the Shawnee National Forest (Illinois). Carbondale, IL. 39 pp.
  3. Evans, M. Botanist/Field Representative, Kentucky Nature Preserves Commission.
  4. Flora of North America Editorial Committee (FNA). 2009. Flora of North America north of Mexico. Vol. 8. Magnoliophyta: Paeoniaceae to Ericaceae. Oxford University Press, New York. xxiv + 585 pp.
  5. Hauser, L. A., T. J. Crovello and J. A. Bacone. 1981. Status report: Dodecatheon frenchii. Indiana Department of Natural Resources report to USFWS, Twin Cities, MN. 10 pp.
  6. Hill, S. R. 2002. Conservation assessment for French's Shootingstar (Dodecatheon frenchii (Vasey) Rydb.). Center for Biodiversity.  Illinois Natural History Survey, Report prepared for the U.S.D.A Forest Service.
  7. Homoya, Mike. Personal communication. Botanist/Plant Ecologist. Indiana Department of Natural Resources, Division of Nature Preserves. Indianapolis, IN.
  8. Kartesz, J.T. 1994. A synonymized checklist of the vascular flora of the United States, Canada, and Greenland. 2nd edition. 2 vols. Timber Press, Portland, OR.
  9. Kurz, D. R. and M. L. Bowles. 1981. Status survey: Dodecatheon frenchii. Unpublished Illinois Department of Conservation, Springfield. 16 pp.
  10. Macior, L. W. 1970. Pollination ecology of dodecatheon amethystinum (Primulaceae). Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 97(3): 150-153.
  11. Mast, A. R., and J. L. Reveal. 2007. Transfer of <i>Dodecatheon </i>to <i>Primula </i>(Primulaceae). Brittonia 59: 79-82.
  12. Mohlenbrock, R. H. 1978. Flowering plants: hollies to loases. The Illustrated Flora of Illinois. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale.
  13. Nelson, P. 1979. Frenches shooting star (Dodecatheon frenchii) revealed in Missouri. Missouriensis 1(1): 7-8.
  14. Oberle, B. and E. J. Esselman. 2011. Fruit and seed characters help distinguish southern Illinois Dodecatheon (Primulaceae) species and highlight unusual intergrading populations. Rhodora 113(955):  280-299.
  15. Olah, L. V. and R. A. DeFilipps. 1968. A cytotaxonomic study of French's shooting star. Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 95: 186-198.
  16. Olah, L. V. and R. A. DeFilipps. 1969. Oversize Dodecatheon frenchii in Illinois. Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 96: 378-379.
  17. Schwegman, John. Botany Program, Illinois Dept. of Conservation. Personal communication.
  18. Tucker, G. 1982. Status survey: Dodecatheon frenchii. Report to USFWS, Atlanta, GA. 29 pp.
  19. Tucker, G. Forest Botanist, Ozark-St. Francis National Forests.
  20. Underwood, Malissa. Personal communication. Botanist. Missouri Natural Heritage Program.
  21. Voigt, J. W. and J. R. Swayne. 1955. French's shooting star in southern Illinois. Rhodora 57(684): 325-332.